Issue on modules - mapping

[Pascal Huau]

Roggerio,

it seems to me that the actual question is: why do we need in the module ARM
such an abstract concept that has no equivalent in the IRs?
In this particular case, I would say that you should remove the arm entity.

In general case, as module mims are intended to be based on IRs, when an arm
concept cannot be mapped, then the IRs should be amended to complete this
new concept.

Regards,
P. Huau
Association GOSET
107,111 avenue Georges Clemenceau
92000 NANTERRE
FRANCE

----- Original Message -----
From: "Barra, Rogerio" <Barra at aticorp.org>
To: <jfowler at pdtsolutions.co.uk>
Cc: <dmprice at us.ibm.com>; <wg10 at steptools.com>;
<pfeifer at dik.tu-darmstadt.de>
Sent: Wednesday, November 08, 2000 3:43 PM
Subject: Issue on modules - mapping


>
>
> Julian,
>
> During the shape appearance and layers modules ballot (1001-1009) the
> following issue was submitted:
>
> Issue Reference No.: GER-1001-14
> Originator: Ullrich Pfeifer - pfeifer at dik.tu-darmstadt.de
> Date:
> Urgency/Type: major, technical Page: clause 5.1
> Sentence/abstract/keywords:
> Issue Description:
> there is no mapping for appearance
>
> Proposed Solutions/Remarks:
> add mapping or explanation
>
> Resolution:
> Entity appearance is an abstract supertype whose subtypes are only known
in
> modules that use 1001 (e.g., part 1009 - Shape Appearance and Layers). As
a
> result, it is not mapped in part 1001. This issue will be forwarded to the
> Quality Committee.
>
>
> I have been told to get input from QC on this issue. My point of view is
> that, in modules, we may have abstract types that are placeholders and
> therefore the mapping is not known. These abstract types will have
subtypes
> in modules that reference the module being specified. The mapping
therefore
> should be defined in the subtypes.
>
> I would appreciate your input on this issue.
>
> Regards,
>
> Rogerio
>
>
> --------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
> -------------------
> Rogerio Barra, Ph.D. mailto:barra at aticorp.org
> Advanced Technology Institute Voice : (843) 760-3378
> 5300 International Blvd. Fax    : (843)760-3349
> N. Charleston, SC  29418 http://www.aticorp.org/
>
>